Published in the Washington Post, Sunday, August 20, 2006
Writing Off Reading
By Michael Skube
We were talking informally in class not long ago, 17 college sophomores and I, and on a whim I asked who some of their favorite writers are. The question hung in uneasy silence. At length, a voice in the rear hesitantly volunteered the name of . . . Dan Brown.
No other names were offered.
The author of "The DaVinci Code" was not just the best writer they could think of; he was the only writer they could think of.
In our better private universities and flagship state schools today, it's hard to find a student who graduated from high school with much lower than a 3.5 GPA, and not uncommon to find students whose GPAs were 4.0 or higher. They somehow got these suspect grades without having read much. Or if they did read, they've given it up. And it shows -- in their writing and even in their conversation.
A few years ago, I began keeping a list of everyday words that may as well have been potholes in exchanges with college students. It began with a fellow who was two months away from graduating from a well-respected Midwestern university.
"And what was the impetus for that?" I asked as he finished a presentation.
At the word "impetus" his head snapped sideways, as if by reflex. "The what?" he asked.
"The impetus. What gave rise to it? What prompted it?"
I wouldn't have guessed that impetus was a 25-cent word. But I also wouldn't have guessed that "ramshackle" and "lucid" were exactly recondite, either. I've had to explain both. You can be dead certain that today's college students carry a weekly planner. But they may or may not own a dictionary, and if they do own one, it doesn't get much use. ("Why do you need a dictionary when you can just go online?" more than one student has asked me.)
You may be surprised -- and dismayed -- by some of the words on my list.
"Advocate," for example. Neither the verb nor the noun was immediately clear to students who had graduated from high school with GPAs above 3.5. A few others:
"Derelict," as in neglectful.
"Satire," as in a literary form.
"Pith," as in the heart of the matter.
"Brevity," as in the quality of being succinct.
And my favorite: "Novel," as in new and as a literary form. College students nowadays call any book, fact or fiction, a novel. I have no idea why this is, but I first became acquainted with the peculiarity when a senior at one of the country's better state universities wrote a paper in which she referred to "The Prince" as "Machiavelli's novel."
As freshmen start showing up for classes this month, colleges will have a new influx of high school graduates with gilded GPAs, and it won't be long before one professor whispers to another: Did no one teach these kids basic English? The unhappy truth is that many students are hard-pressed to string together coherent sentences, to tell a pronoun from a preposition, even to distinguish between "then" and "than." Yet they got A's.
How does one explain the inability of college students to read or write at even a high school level? One explanation, which owes as much to the culture as to the schools, is that kids don't read for pleasure. And because they don't read, they are less able to navigate the language. If words are the coin of their thought, they're working with little more than pocket change.
Say this -- but no more -- for the Bush administration's No Child Left Behind Act: It at least recognizes the problem. What we're graduating from our high schools isn't college material. Sometimes it isn't even good high school material.
When students with A averages can't write simple English, it shouldn't be surprising that people ask what a high school diploma is really worth. In California this year, hundreds of high school students, many with good grades, faced the prospect of not graduating because they could not pass a state-mandated exit exam. Although a judge overturned the effort, legislators (not always so literate themselves) in other states have also called for exit exams. It's hardly unreasonable to ask that students demonstrate a minimum competency in basic subjects, especially English.
Exit exams have become almost a necessity because the GPA is not to be trusted. In my experience, a high SAT score is far more reliable than a high GPA -- more indicative of quickness and acuity, and more reflective of familiarity with language and ideas. College admissions specialists are of a different view and are apt to label the student with high SAT scores but mediocre grades unmotivated, even lazy.
I'll take that student any day. I've known such students. They may have been bored in high school but they read widely and without prodding from a parent. And they could have nominated a few favorite writers besides Dan Brown -- even if they thoroughly enjoyed "The DaVinci Code."
I suspect they would have understood the point I tried unsuccessfully to make once when I quoted Joseph Pulitzer to my students. It is journalism's job, he said, to comfort the afflicted and afflict the comfortable. Too obvious, you think? I might have thought so myself -- if the words "afflicted" and "afflict" hadn't stumped the whole class.
Michael Skube teaches journalism at Elon University in Elon, N.C.
Link to online story.
(Note: Online stories may be taken down by their publisher after a period of time or made available for a fee. Links posted here is from the original online publication of this piece.)
(In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. Plainfield Today, Plainfield Stuff and Clippings have no affiliation whatsoever with the originator of these articles nor are Plainfield Today, Plainfield Stuff or Clippings endorsed or sponsored by the originator.)
- ► 2008 (87)
- ► 2007 (156)
- Iraq - Wash Post - Biden: A plan
- Negotiating - Ledger - How to haggle: Power negoti...
- Police Escorts - Courier - Editorial: Mayoral body...
- Dems - NCR - Seek to revive 'common good' as new s...
- Obituary - NCR - Sr. Mary Luke Tobin, took part in...
- Mayor Robinson-Briggs - Courier - Gets police esco...
- Real Estate - NY Times - Chart, 1890 - 2005
- Real Estate - NY Times - Overview 1890-2005
- Illegal Immigrants - Herald News - Ordinance divid...
- Language competence- Wash Post - Skube: "Writing o...
- Computers - Chicago Tribune - Hiding stuff in plai...
- How-to - Yahoo Finance - Sucess...anywhere
- Pittis Carillon - The Carillon Keyboard and Playin...
- Pittis Carillon - Trevor Workman - Carillonneur to...
- Housing - NY Times - Krugman: Housing gets ugly
- House Tour - September 10, 2006
- Redevelopment - Map - Cottage Place/East 3rd/Richm...
- Casablanca - I'm shocked!
- Pay-to-Play - Courier Post - County party committe...
- Policing - Courier - Plainfield and selected towns...
- Iraq War - Austin Statesman - Sheehan group protes...
- Book Review - WashPost - Juan Williams: Enough
- Crime - Courier - Editorial: No crime news is good...
- Crime - Courier - City wants crime to be trend
- Letter - Courier - Editorial Ignores Dem Machine
- Farber resignation - PoliticsNJ - Selected items
- Union County honored for Park-Madison complex
- Plainfield - Transportation Museum Proposal - 1998...
- BP - NY Times - Green logo, but BP is old oil
- Gangs - Ledger - Recruiting youngsters
- The Auditor - Ledger - August 13, 2006
- Poem - The Bridge Builder - Will Allen Dromgoole
- Development - Hevesi Release - Developer trick: Un...
- Development - NY Times - Developer trick: Understa...
- Tax reform - Courier - Public benefit plans assail...
- Robbery - Courier - Motorist robbed at knifepoint,...
- Council - Courier - Editorial: Latinos deserved cl...
- Blanco - Courier - Memorial Service
- Menendez - Ledger - Lesniak fundraiser features Bi...
- Catullus - Poem 101 - On the death of his brother
- Pension Contributions - Ledger - Plainfield Data
- Route 78 - Ledger - Commuter help online
- Farber - Courier - Questions abound in probe
- House Tour - Courier - Queen City readies for Sept...
- Block Association clinic and kickoff set for Satur...
- Farber - Ledger - Corzine stifles questioning on F...
- Farber - Courier - Willing to appear before Judici...
- Immigratrion - NY Times - OpEd: On Schwarzenegger'...
- Members of 4 Tax Reform Committees
- ▼ August (49)
- Plainfield resident since 1983. Retired as the city's Public Information Officer in 2006; prior to that Community Programs Coordinator for the Plainfield Public Library. Founding member and past president of: Faith, Bricks & Mortar; Residents Supporting Victorian Plainfield; and PCO (the outreach nonprofit of Grace Episcopal Church). Supporter of the Library, Symphony and Historic Society as well as other community groups, and active in Democratic politics.